reenactor.Net's Online, Reenacting Events Calendar
Our Reenacting Events Calendar

reenactor.Net's Main Page
Ancient Periods of History
The Middle Ages
1600-1800
The Frontier Period
Native American Reenacting
1800-1865
The American Civil War
1870-1900
World War I
World War II
1946-Present

Add a Reenacting Unit Link button art

EMC Militaria micro ad

How to Re-Size Photos for posting on this site.

Marsh's Blog

This site is Gunny Approved
Lost Battalions (P)

Poll

Would you openly accept QUALITY civilian impressions at tactical battles? (displaced persons or resistance/partisans)

Yes! It would be a refreshing addition to the same shoot-em-ups.
4 (66.7%)
Only if their action was directly controlled by the event organizers.
2 (33.3%)
Don't care either way.
0 (0%)
No; might interfere with an otherwise quality tactical event.
0 (0%)
No way! Anyone who does such an impression is a cheapskate, non-conformist, and I'll "execute" them when I see them in the battle!
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 6

Voting closed: September 14, 2007, 11:40:25 PM

Author Topic: Civilians in WW2 tactical events  (Read 18675 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Philonivs Maximvs

  • Trooper
  • *
  • Posts: 97
  • Karma: +7/-2
Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« on: September 07, 2007, 11:40:25 PM »
I am on a kick to possibly start doing civilian WW2 (specifically western European displaced persons). I'd just like to get a feel for what people think about such a thing.
"I drank WHAT???" ---Socrates

Offline Antonescu

  • Reenactor
  • *
  • Posts: 333
  • Karma: +5/-1
  • "Soldiers, cross the River Prut"
    • WWII Living History Association
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #1 on: September 09, 2007, 12:56:22 AM »
I'd have to say it would depend on what you want to do as a civilian.
"Those who forget the past are condemned to relive it" George Santayana (1863-1952)
4th SS Polizei Division http://www.wwiilha.com/4thssmain.html
318th, 80th ID AEF http://www.hardscrabblefarm.com/80th/

reenactor.Net, THE Online, Worldwide Home of Living History

Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #1 on: September 09, 2007, 12:56:22 AM »
Lost Battalions (P)

Offline Philonivs Maximvs

  • Trooper
  • *
  • Posts: 97
  • Karma: +7/-2
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #2 on: September 09, 2007, 05:43:46 PM »
Of course! Like I said somewhere else, it can be an "anything goes" type of impression, as long as your clothing is authentic for the period and location. Russian peasants wouldn't be wearing too many fedoras and flannels!
"I drank WHAT???" ---Socrates

Offline atlanticwallblanks

  • Trooper
  • *
  • Posts: 85
  • Karma: +5/-1
    • Atlantic Wall Blanks
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #3 on: September 16, 2007, 02:53:09 PM »
I have no problem with it as long as they have a bit of experience at the hobby and know enough not to get themselves hurt.

Civilians were there and in the way at times.   

Let me know how many times you are shot  :P

Robb

Offline Philonivs Maximvs

  • Trooper
  • *
  • Posts: 97
  • Karma: +7/-2
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #4 on: September 16, 2007, 10:42:50 PM »
Haha, yeah, I would expect the "uuleets" to want to get some atrocities in.

Agreed... at least the "leaders" of the civilian group should be experienced reenactors, with a direct line to the commander(s) of the event. That is, unless they are partisan/resistance that have already joined the front lines.
"I drank WHAT???" ---Socrates

Offline battlebaby4

  • Reenactor
  • *
  • Posts: 144
  • Karma: +3/-0
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #5 on: October 29, 2007, 03:00:42 PM »
I  believe civilians would be great in judged tacticals like we did in CW many years ago in Rockton , Canada or Brush Creek,PA.
 Theses tacticals was great. A sniper would kill off the officers,NCO's, privates would have to figure what to do. Run into sick civilians, give them food, water ect. Get info from them. We had hooker's one time too with them.
A unit could get 10 pts per station or lose 10 pts too. Bad tactics, poor hit taking, mean to friendly civilians ect. We would be attacked by cav and have to fend them off. Canon shots ect. All was in period talking,food everything. If you were caught talking about modern stuff, points lost ect.
 For WW 2 we could do a whole lot more. Many units would find out if they could really make it or not. Could change the outlook for many folks, a thinking tactical with real missions and plans.
I'm game to start one again--

 Pat
99th Infantry Division, 393rd Regiment, Easy Co. "Battlebabies"

Offline Philonivs Maximvs

  • Trooper
  • *
  • Posts: 97
  • Karma: +7/-2
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #6 on: October 29, 2007, 04:29:17 PM »
Sweet... where abouts are you?

I only have a handful of scattered people that I've talked to here in the Midwest that would be willing to do it. We'll see.... I keep talking it up, maybe soon we'll start having some interest.
"I drank WHAT???" ---Socrates

Offline dbloge

  • Plebe
  • *
  • Posts: 19
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #7 on: October 29, 2007, 09:05:47 PM »
im from the midwest as well.........i think tacticals should be for uniformed troops only.........if your a civilian without a weapon you are useless........tacticals are a time for units to work together and improve their impression..........its not only for busting caps..........if you want to do an impression that is non german or american.................how about russian.....their numbers can use the help



doug
2nd panzer

Offline Philonivs Maximvs

  • Trooper
  • *
  • Posts: 97
  • Karma: +7/-2
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #8 on: October 29, 2007, 10:44:03 PM »
Well, some of us are just thinking of one of the major missing factors in reenacting... that is of civilians "getting in the way" or helping out either side. I think civilians can introduce a "wild card" into the same old bang-bang-shootemups that you have now. Troops historically were always running into civilians, and besides constant artillery barrages, it's the one detail that we could easily fix with the proper people. Sure, the regular units can keep shooting... I don't understand where you think civilian impressions would be that useless.

I'm lost as to how tacticals can be used to improve impressions though.... I thought that was what the time in between events was! You know: ordering things, sewing up stuff, making props, etc. I tend to think that a unit's overall impression goes DOWN several notches at tacticals just by the nature of it all: shooting blanks at each other, putting up with people calling hits & acting like babies, the usual. I'm not saying that tacticals are stupid, they just have limitations. But it can be more, in my opinion. I also think that public displays, or better yet immersion events where you don't necessarily shoot (or even have an adversary... just "live" in the moment), are better avenues for authenticity & realism.

And I DO Russian already, but thanks :)
"I drank WHAT???" ---Socrates

Offline adam

  • Plebe
  • *
  • Posts: 16
  • Karma: +1/-0
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #9 on: October 30, 2007, 11:55:29 AM »
I would think that, if you're interested in improving your impression, adding civilians to the mix would be a plus. Think about it: you're already keyed up knowing that you're going to be engaged with the enemy and you run into some civilians. What are they doing here? Are they lost or are they resistance? If you let them pass (after checking their papers, of course), are they going go about their business, or is their business killing you? Are you walking into a trap, have they reported your movements to the enemy, are you going to be caught in a crossfire between the enemy and those same kind citizens you just let pass? It goes the same for both sides. So, yeah, I would think civilians would be a usefull way to improve one's impression.

Offline battlebaby4

  • Reenactor
  • *
  • Posts: 144
  • Karma: +3/-0
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #10 on: October 30, 2007, 04:34:51 PM »
I am from Erie ,Pa. Some more on this type of tactical. They normally have both militray and civilians mixed into them. Units will all folllow the same route at different times. A german unit would go  1st then GI , then german. At each station you have only so many minutes to work out the problem.Staying too long the enemy cound be on your back.
 We could have a small convoy, it gets hit, vehicles smoking, what would the unit do. Civilians with a broken down wagon with wounded. Objectives could be finding a POW camp, ammo dump, searching for a spy in area ect. Tons of ideas and stations could be set-up.
 For one event in CW like this we only have 20 shots, till we got to the ammo dump to refill. You couldn't just burn powder every shot counted. I had to take ammo off our dead. Carring wounded men to the hospital really slows you down. One time each unit had a traitor in the unit. His job was to kill the officer. Out of 8 units all officers were killed by their most trusted man.
 A wooded park area or village mueeum would be the best area for events like this. We had bridges to use with roadways too.
 A idea for maybe the future--  Pat
99th Infantry Division, 393rd Regiment, Easy Co. "Battlebabies"

Offline marloes

  • Plebe
  • *
  • Posts: 19
  • Karma: +2/-0
    • The Netherlands 1940-1945, Study and Living History Group
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #11 on: October 30, 2007, 05:10:53 PM »
Our group ONLY portrays civilians in occupied areas and we've been doing so for a few years now.
We take authenticity as serious as the most obsessed military groups, we aim for our clothing, paperwork, bavkgroundstory, etc to be perfect.
99% of the events we go to are Living History public events, not battles.
And because were situated in a country that was once occupied we have to be very sensetive.

We have written guidelines for our interaction with other groups;
http://nederland4045.nl/richtlijnen/

And here is our group;
http://nederland4045.nl


Authentic Radiobroadcasts for your display;
http://www.joeri.net/radiofiles

Offline dbloge

  • Plebe
  • *
  • Posts: 19
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #12 on: October 31, 2007, 01:38:15 AM »
in a perfect world the time in between events would be spent training.........ie...handsignals, combat movement..........maybe i just cant understand portraying a civilian at a tactical........if you dont have a weapon..............what do you do?.........i go to tacticals to bust caps.....am a bad guy for liking to do that?..........i havent tried a wwii emersion event but it souinds pretty cool


doug
aurora il

Offline marloes

  • Plebe
  • *
  • Posts: 19
  • Karma: +2/-0
    • The Netherlands 1940-1945, Study and Living History Group
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #13 on: October 31, 2007, 07:55:37 AM »
Well i couldnt care less about fighting and shooting so I wouldnt go to tacticals anyway.
But civilians would make the battle more interesting and realistic.
For instance, imagine stumbling upon some refugees, scared, harmless, not knowing where to hide.
What do you do, can you trust them, do you check their paperwork, do you ignore them?
Do they get in the way thanking you for liberating them while enemy is in the area or do they give your position away and give information about you to the enemy?
Or perhaps they help you.


Authentic Radiobroadcasts for your display;
http://www.joeri.net/radiofiles

Offline Philonivs Maximvs

  • Trooper
  • *
  • Posts: 97
  • Karma: +7/-2
Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #14 on: October 31, 2007, 09:34:27 AM »
Well said, Joeri!

Doug, you aren't a bad guy! I appreciate that you are there for the shooting, but a lot of us are about putting the "acting" in reenacting. We're just looking for that added dimension.... I've been doing this hobby for 12 years now, and the shooting isn't why I go anymore, unless it promises to be a good scenario. Otherwise, the same old goofiness with people not taking hits, whining about other people not taking hits, bad field discipline, it all starts to wear on you after a while. Perhaps not you though! That's cool, we're all in this for slightly different reasons sometimes.

And I do agree with you, units need to buckle down and learn the proper period commands, signals, and basic tactics. I think dedicated training events are where it's at when it comes to this... you simply can't do a whole lot at the regular events with everyone arriving at different times, wanting to socialize/drink, etc, everything BUT training.

Immersion is awesome when done properly... some events are tactical, some are not. The whole point of an immersion is to get completely into the period, and this is usually done by camping tactically, running round-the-clock patrols, delegating mundane tasks (like digging foxholes, running communications lines, etc). The best one I've been to was at Rensselaer, IN (after I stopped running them there) where we did a 24-hour & stayed in the bunker all night and took turns watching for Amis.

And speaking of civilians, your Spiess (Chris Chalupa) came out a couple years before that at Rensselaer and portrayed an Estonian man who rode around on his bike creating confusion on both sides! He was working for the Germans, but telling the Russians he was working for them (all the while giving them disinformation). The German commander didn't trust him though, which added to the confusion.
"I drank WHAT???" ---Socrates

reenactor.Net, THE Online, Worldwide Home of Living History

Re: Civilians in WW2 tactical events
« Reply #14 on: October 31, 2007, 09:34:27 AM »
Lost Battalions (P)